PowerSwap

On Dec. 10th 2003, I placed the challenge below in my LiveJournal and the response was astonishing:  50+ stories of varying length.  Each new story was added in the order in which I received notice of it, although several entries by one writer are all grouped together.  Most have summaries, though a few authors never submitted one.  There were also three different RPGs that emerged, two of them being: X-Axis and X-Repowered.  In addition, a Buffy AU swap appeared, begun by one of the players in X-Axis, called Shrimpless.  Clearly, people have had some fun!

Powerswap I've seen several mix-n-match-power AUs, and they always have the potential to be a lot of fun, as it's often remarked how much a mutant's particular power shapes his or her personality.  So write a movieverse story featuring -- but not limited to -- Scott and Jean, in which the characters have radically different powers.  That means don't give Scott Jean's telepathy or Logan's healing factor.  Give him, oh, Magneto's powers, or Jubilee's, or Bobby's, or Sabretooth's.  Give Jean Marrow's powers, or Mystique's, or Colossus', or Gambit's.  It's perfectly acceptable to borrow powers from ANY comic-X-verse character, BUT try to change little or nothing else about Jean and Scott's backgrounds or appearances, unless affected by their (new) mutation (including Scott's status as a handicapped mutant).  They came from the same families, have basically the same talents, etc.

How would they be different people?  How would they be the same?

Other characters may keep their normal mutations or not, and Scott and Jean don't necessarily have to be a romantic pair.  They don't even both have to be X-Men.

I guess this is kinda a "nature or nurture?" question -- with a twist.


(It wasn't just writers who got inspired.  The manipulated images in the title pic above were done by Erin, the artwork below for "Under the Stairs" was done by L.K. Malnassy, and for "He Who Has Ears to Hear" by Bounce.)

No mention of what the new mutations are, since that's part of the fun.

"Pillar of the Dream" and "Dominos," by Obi-Wago Kenobi
(1) As with everything worth building, the X-Men need a sturdy foundation (a retelling of X1) and (2) Some things, no matter how unpleasant, are inevitable (sequel to first, prelude to X2)

"Opposites Attract," by Penknife
Need isn't the same things as love.

"The Silence in Screaming" and "Meant to Fly," by Ally
(1) The only screaming he does these days is within his own mind, and (2)  He always knew he was meant to fly.

"Contact," by Anne-Cara
He is never alone.  They torment him, mock him, argue with him, analyze his actions as if he weren't supporting their lives.  Only one thing can quiet them, the one thing he can't truly have.

"Winter's Hinterland," by Ninamonkey
Holidays are bad enough without seeing your ex-girlfriend with someone new.


"Down the Rabbit Hole," By Mara Greengrass
Four possible faces of Scott Summers.

"Abnormality," by Jon Seitzer
Loving someone is never normal, especially when you compare it to an ocean.

"Nightmares," by Alia
Some problems only have absolute answers.

"Sacrifice Served," "Dance with the Devil," and "When I'm Gone," by Tracy
(1) An angel has lost his wings [post X1], and (2) For what would a man give up his soul?
(3) The current third is an unrelated additional story:  when you love someone, you are the ultimate sacrifice.

"One More Face," by Bekka
A morphing mutant takes drastic steps towards a future she's not sure she wants.

"Broken Home," by Alara Rogers
Because divorce is hell on the kids, even the grown ones. (Focuses on Scott & Erik)

"Let You See Me," by Neva Caruso
The good guys sticks around ... unless he can only prove it by leaving.

"Brass Knuckles," by Bounce

"An Occasional Slip," by RaeDances

"Beauty and the Beast," by  Devin Harris
Scott's introspection on his powers (vignette)

"Fallout," "The Seeds Bear Fruit," and "Startling," by Wyzeguy
(1) Sometimes even powerswapped abilities aren't enough to change a conflict's outcome. (Takes place during X1), (2) Magneto muses on his past history with Xavier's School, as years of careful planning produce interesting results (post X1, followup to "Fallout.") (3) Scott returns to the mansion ... and brings the rest of the Brotherhood with him. (Jean's POV)


"Quiet" and "An Eye for an Eye for an Eye," by TrollPrincess
(1) Scott loves Jean, even if he can't say it, and (2) the line to kiss Jean hello forms to the left.

"So Many Ways to Say I Love You," by Katta
Hjärpe
In certain situations, a weakness can be an asset.

Marrow Scott "Wrong Turn," by Catecumen
A traveler reflects upon her unexpected destination.

"Under the Stairs," by Dex
Xavier's most useful monsters live under the stairs, only to emerge when they can be denied.

"Spot, the Vampire Cat," by Bynon Carget

"A Touch of Freedom," by Naomi Kraus
Sometimes you need to close a door to free your mind and body.

"Trapped in the Ice," by Eleanor Jane
Scott needs Jean to remain human; what does Jean need?

"The Tyranny of Distance," by innle
Scott can't reach.  Part Three of "Four Things Cyclops Never Saw," which is worth reading in full.

"Secret Weapons," by Andraste
Charles Xavier will do what whatever is nedcessary to protect his homd and family.

"Marie, Marie, Quite Contrary" and "tyger, tyger, burning bright," by  paradigm Seven
(1) "I've been good, don't you see, I've been good and haven't tried to mess with their heads and I haven't tried to leech them dry and I haven't done anything wrong except being me."  (2) "He needs this," she remembered the professor saying, oh so many years ago.

"Left Behind," "Hatred" and "Cocaphony of Silence," by Frosty
(1) Ever feel like the weather is ganging up on you?  Scott does.  (2) There is always hope, even in the darkest situations.  (3) Sometimes it's not good to talk.  It's even worse to scream.

"Heart of Darkness," by Rossi
In a time of tension after Stryker's attack, Jean visits their secret weapon in the basement.

Cypher ScottHow the Leopard Changed Her Spots, by Minisinoo
A different Scott, a different Jean.  Montague and Capulet.  This retelling of X1 consists of four stories: "Till We Have Faces," "He Who Has Ears to Hear," "How the Leopard Changed Her Spots," and "A Rose by Any Other Name Still Has Thorns."

"Weapon X," by Sigil
Hope was offered to an out-of-control mutant, but the price was freedom. (Set in X2)

"The Amazing Scott," "The Amazing Scott II," "X-Men: Legacy," and "Two Origin Stories," by Turlock
(1) Scott reminisces about his power's origin while being bored in the mansion and waiting for Jean to return from a mission. (2-4) more in the TAS world.

"Twenty-Four Hours (of Silent Agony)," by Faechick

"Drawing in a Mirror," by C. Elisa
"If you know what is going to happen to people, and not what has happened to them, it makes it difficult to prevent it happening, if you don't want it to have happened, if you see what I mean?  Like drawing in a mirror."  (Merlyn in The Once and Future King)

"Hands of a Healer," by Renjenri
All surgeons learn that this is not an ideal world.

"Form and Illusion," by ShalNyx

"Simple," by Stefanie
After a member of the X-Men is kidnapped, the professor sends Scott out to rescue her.

"Le Chateau des Pyrenees," by TangledAria
"There are many paths to the top of the mountain, but the view is always the same."

"Kneeling Demon" and "Salvation," by Nadja Lee
1) "Even a demon can fall on bended knee before an angel," 2) "I can save these people; it's both my right and my duty."

"Musings of a Troubled Mutant," by Yo

"They All Fall Down," by Just Like Rogue
A doctor in a pysch ward meets a new patient.

"Origins of a Slightly Different Perspective," by A.J.
Sometimes even the most tragic events can lead to something wonderful ... or something far worse.

"Beginnings," by Crys Clouse
A different Scott comes to the mansion and meets a different Charles for the first time. (This was especially inspired by the convo about how Charles and the school could work if Charles wasn't a Telepath.)  One part up so far.


Site Meter